The Entangled Eastern Front and the Making of the Ukrainian State: a Forgotten Peace – a Forgotten War and Nation-Building

  • Post Category:Issue XIX

Mark von Hagen
American historian, Professor of Russian, Ukrainian and Eurasian history at the University of Arizona (USA)

DOI https://doi.org/10.37837/2707-7683-2018-2

Abstract. In his article the author reproduced a picture of the Ukrainian state formation and described the stages of the independence movement deployment. Despite all the efforts — conscious or unconscious — of the numerous “authors” of Ukrainian statehood, there were always powerful forces who opposed the idea of Ukraine’s independence. The Bolsheviks and Whites showed the most hostile attitude towards the idea of the Ukrainian state and nation. This was confirmed by the devastating actions of the White Army and the Polish Republic in the western lands of Ukraine. A first war between Soviet Russia and Ukraine poisoned the relations of the two revolutionary governments and ruined the peace among the Ukrainian Bolsheviks. However, because of their state weakness and the urgent need for food for the starving Petrograd and other parts of Russia, Bolsheviks were supposed to pretend that they take their slogans of national self-determination seriously. Even recognizing the Ukrainian People’s Republic and at the same time putting ultimatums on it and threatening war, unless the UNR surrenders its armed forces and statehood to the subject of the Bolsheviks.
The author explored the process of German-Austrian occupation of Ukraine, noting that the occupation in wartime is characterized by the features of colonial regimes of exploitation and subordination, which vividly and at the same time sadly demonstrates the presence of the Central Powers in Ukraine in 1918. By strengthening the Ukrainian government they had contracted with and promised military and political support, the Germans were simultaneously weakening and undermining it because of their inflated demands. The article also analyzes the limited sovereignty of the Ukrainian state, describes the attitude to the idea of the Ukrainian state and the nation of other peoples.
Keywords: Ukrainian state, independence, sovereignty, occupation, Bolsheviks, Soviet Russia, Central states.

Download Article (ukr) / (eng)

References
1. Szporluk, R. (2006). Lenin, ‘Great Russia,’ and Ukraine. Harvard Ukrainian Studies, 28/1–4, pp. 611-626. [in Ukrainian]
2. Lapchinsky, G. (1927). Z pershykh dniv vseukrainskoyi vlady [From the first days of the Ukrainian government]; Idem, ‘Pershyi period radians’koi vlady na Ukraini. TsVKU ta Narodniy Sekretariiat (Spohady)’ [The first period of soviet power in Ukraine. The CECU and the People’s Secretariat (Memoirs), in: Ibid. 1 (1928), pp. 160-175; and Borotba za Kyiv: Sichen 1918 r. 1918 [The Battle for Kyiv: January 1918]. Litopys revolutsii, no. 2(29), p. 219. [in Ukrainian]
3. Antonov-Ovseenko, V. Zapiski [Notes], vol. 1, p. 154. [in Russian]
4. Pidhainy, O. (1966). The Formation of the Ukrainian Repuplic. New York, p. 599. [in English]
5. Doroshenko, D. (1923–1924). Moi spomyny pro nedavne-mynule 1914-1918 [My Reminiscences Concerning the Distant Past]. 4 vols, vol. 1, p. 294. [in Ukrainian]
6. Lapchinskyi, Borotba za Kyiv [The Battle for Kyiv], p. 219. [in Ukrainian]
7. Antonov-Ovseenko, Zapiski [Notes], vol. 1, p. 157. [in Russian]
8. Khrystiuk, P. (1921). Zamitky i materialy do istorii ukrainskoi revolutsii, 1917–1920 rr. [Notes], vol. 2, Wien, pp. 181-184. [in Ukrainian]
9. Hornykiewicz, T. (ed.). ‘Aufregung in Polen wegen Angliederung Cholms an die Ukraine’, in Ereignisse in der Ukraine 1914–1922, vol. 2, pp. 229-275. [in German]
10. Fedyshyn, O. (1971). Germany’s Drive to the East and the Ukrainian Revolution 1917–1918, p. 77. [in English]
11. Hoffmann, M. (1924). The War of Lost Opportunities, p. 230. [in English]
12. Bihl, W. Österreich-Ungarn und die Friedensschlüsse von Brest-Litovsk, p. 198. [in German]
13. The appeal was drafted by the one Ukrainian delegate left in Brest-Litovsk, Liubynskyi.
14. Hornykiewicz (ed.), Ereignisse, vol. 2, p. 276-290. [in German]
15. Bihl, Friedensschlüsse von Brest-Litovsk, p. 126. [in German]
16. Haswell Lutz, R. (ed.), Fall of the German Empire, 1914–1918, 2 vols, vol. 1. New York: Hoover War Library, pp. 802-828.
17. Hornykiewicz (ed.), Ereignisse, vol. 1, pp. 287-290, doc. 116.
18. Arkhiv russkoi revoliutsii [Archive of the Russian Revolution]. (1922–1937). 22 vols, vol. 1. Berlin, pp. 368-376. [in Russian]
19. Horak, S. (1988). The First Treaty of World War I, pp. 91-99. [in English]
20. Verstiuk, V., Ostashko, T. (eds). (1997). Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada [Ukrainian Central Rada], vol. 2, p. 155, doc. 77. [in Ukrainian]
21. Bihl, Friedensschlüsse von Brest-Litovsk, pp. 106-113.
22. Verstiuk, Ostashko, Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada [Ukrainian Central Rada], p. 160, doc. 81. [in Ukrainian]
23. Joukoff Eudin, X. (1941). The German Occupation of the Ukraine in 1918. The Russian Review, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 90-105 [in English] doi:10.2307/125435;
24. Hunczak, T. (1977). The Ukraine Under Hetman Pavlo Skoropadskyi, in idem (ed.), The Ukraine, 1917–1921: A Study in Revolution, pp. 61-81;
25.Borowsky, P. (1970). Deutsche Ukrainepolitik 1918 unter besonderer Berücksichtigung der Wirtschaftsfragen. Historische Studien, vol. 416 [in German] doi:10.1086/240831;
26. Gratz, G., Schüller, R. (1925). Die äussere Wirtschaftspolitik Oesterreich-Ungarns: Mitteleuropäische Plaene. Wien (The economic policy of Austria-Hungary during the war in its external relations (1928). Economic and social history of the World War, vol. 4. New Haven [in English];
27. Kerchnawe, H. (1918). Die Militärverwaltung in den von den österreichisch-ungarischen Truppen besetzten Gebieten. Wien, pp. 359-390 [in German].
28. Von Hagen, M. (2007). ‘War in a European Borderland: Occupations and Occupation Plans in Galicia and Ukraine, 1914–1918’, in Donald, W. (2007). Treadgold Studies on Russia, East Europe, and Central Asia. Seattle, pp. 87-104 https://doi.org/10.1017/s0037677900016892
29. See Ludendorff’s ‘General Directives of the Administration and Exploitation of the Occupied Eastern regions after the Conclusion of the Peace Treaty’, part B devoted to Ukraine, March 18, 1918, discussed in Fedyshyn, Drive to the East, p. 113. [in English]
30. Freiherr Hiller von Gaertringen, F. (ed.), Groener, W. Lebenserinnerungen: Jugend, Generalstab, Weltkrieg. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, p. 385. [in German].
31. Rohrbach, P. (1953). Um des Teufels Handschrift: Zwei Menschenalter erlebter Weltgeschichte. Hamburg, p. 221. [in German]
32. Krauss’ report dated 13 June 1918, in Hornykiewicz (ed.), Ereignisse, vol. 3, p. 119.
33. Horak, The First Treaty, p. 107.
34. The American Slavic and East European Review, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 105-115. [in English]
35. Verstiuk, V., Ostashko, T. (eds.), Ukrainska Tsentralna Rada [Ukrainian Central Rada], vol. 2, pp. 184-188, doc. 99 (Liubynskyi, Sevriuk, and Levytskyi all address the government). [in Ukrainian]
36. Erzberger, M. (1959). “My ‘Offensive’ in the Main Committee”, 14 May 1918, in Lutz, R. (ed.), Fall of the German Empire, vol. 1, p. 853.
37. Epstein, K. (1959). Matthias Erzberger and the Dilemma of German Democracy. Princeton, pp. 239-244. [in English]
38. Hornykiewicz (ed.), Ereignisse, vol. 3, p. 74. The Austro-Hungarian Ambassador Forgách described the relationship as ‘eine Art stillschweigendes Protektorat’.
39. Maximilian, Prince of Baden (1928). The Memoirs of Prince Max of Baden, 2 vols, vol. 2. London, p. 274. [in English]
40. Hoffmann, M. (1929). War Diaries and Other Papers, 2 vols, vol. 1. London, p. 246. [in English]
41. Fischer, F. (1967). Germany’s Aims in the First World War. New York, p. 508 [in English]
42. Lansing, R (1921). The Peace Negotiations: A Personal Narrative. Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, p. 99. [in English]
43. Prashad, V. (2011). The Wilsonian moment: Self-determination and the international origins of anticolonial nationalism – By Erez Manela. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007. Pp. 352. Hardback £44.00, ISBN: 978-0-19-517615-5; paperback £12.99, ISBN: 978-0-19-537853-5. Journal of Global History, 6(1), 153-155. doi:10.1017/S174002281100009X.